Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Trish Randall's avatar

It has taken many decades of government, media and Hollywood propagating lies about the nature of pain, the functioning of opioids and the collection of behaviors that they call a disease - addiction.

Pain is not a thing of the mind. Look at the Original Star Trek series from the late 1960s, Spock was able to say "pain is a thing of the mind" and overcome pain with mental effort because he was An Alien, His human shipmates weren't expected to be able to do that.

Opium has been used by humans for thousands of years. Ancient civilizations where opium was used to treat not only pain, but many other conditions, didn't leave reports of people who went anti-social kookoo and overused unto death. Prior to the 1940s, where an opioid user died, the death was attributed to disease, accidents, or other causes, not the opioid. It was only in the 1940s, when NYC heroin dealers started cutting their heroin with a malaria medication, which caused rapid deaths with edema in the lungs that the "he died so fast the needle was still in his arm" trope was introduced to the world. The NY State assistant medical examiner, Dr. Michael Baden spent years trying to get the word out that heroin was not killing people. These days, if there is any link to opioid use, the US government will count the death in the "opioid OD" category.

Addiction &/or alcoholism were considered extremely rare afflictions even late into the 20th century. The hallmarks of addiction were not just illicit use, but habituation and withdrawal symptoms. Withdrawal symptoms were real physical, observable things like vomiting, shaking, goosebumps. In the mid-20th century heroin and tobacco were considered equally addictive. Yet one was illegal, and the other, legal.

Anti-drug story lines inserted into Hollywood productions at government request dramatized terrible outcomes from drug use, even as the terrible outcomes changed over time. In the 1930s, it was Reefer Madness, in the 70s, it was couch potato stoners.

Pain is real, and anyone who is honest would admit that they've had at least one experience of pain that made it impossible to think clearly or function. They seem not to be able to conceive of the fact that such life disruption by pain can be an enduring experience for some people. Perhaps that's because it's too frightening a concept to acknowledge.

The fact that there are doctors who actually did take the real Hyppocratic Oath could be recruited into the ideology that says pain can be overcome without treatment that opioids are only temporarily effective and then only for "some" forms of pain, is disheartening.

Expand full comment
Steve Rose's avatar

Hey Arthritic Chic... "I feel your pain" as a disabled Viet Vet I gave up on the medical/pharma complex 40 years ago. Developed my own protocol to protect and strengthen my immune system.

I do share it however most are not interested. I see people injured by doctors and they go right back to the system that hurt them for help. "Take back your health" seek the truth... Food Not Pharma.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts